I emailed Earlham and they confirmed that every applicant has received either a rejection or phone interview invite email. There is no "long list." So I would email them to find out which you are.
Clearly, my gmail ate mine, coz it isn't even in the spam filter, let alone my inbox (apparently, this also happened to a campus interview invite for another school! I'm glad they bothered to call me, or else I would have never known!). I don't know what's up with that. It was sent to my school email, which forwards to gmail, so maybe gmail has been having some problems with forwarding in the past few days. Do you use gmail?
Anyway: email Earlham.